Half of your new members will quietly stop showing up by month three. Most of them will never tell you why.
That was the starting point for our first joint webinar with the Fitness Industry Council of Canada (FIC) on 12 November, Stop Losing Members: AI for Member Retention. Owners, founders, executives and general managers from clubs and studios across Canada joined Zach Weston, Morgan Thomas, Paula Comfort and me for an honest hour on one question: how do you keep the members you already have, at every location, without adding more work to a team that is already stretched?
Here are the takeaways I keep coming back to. If you missed it, watch the 24-minute replay or read the webinar insights report.
1. Retention is not a marketing problem

Zach opened the session with the line that set the tone for the whole hour. Member retention is one of the top challenges FIC members raise, and it is why FIC and NexScale™ formed a strategic partnership to bring built-in-Canada AI for member retention to Canadian fitness and wellness businesses.
2. The leak is bigger than it looks

Most members do not cancel. They quietly stop coming. In a study of 3,802 new gym members, half had stopped showing up by month three, and 85% by month twelve. Replacing each of them costs at least five times more than keeping them.
The exit survey usually says “too expensive”. In my experience, the real reason is visibility. In a growing studio, nobody has time to notice when a member starts disengaging. In a big one, nobody can.
Yes, you need new leads. But fix the leak first. Then community and word of mouth become your best marketing.
Soodeh Farokhi, PhD, Founder and CEO, NexScale
3. You have about 2.3 months to act

A cancellation is the last event, not the first. Members book less, then come less, then go quiet. Research on 7,752 gym members found about 2.3 months between the drift and the cancellation. That is the window where retention is won or lost, and most of the usual tools miss it:
A save offer at the cancel button. Too late. The member has already decided.
The same email to everyone. Members learn to ignore it.
A risk score or dashboard. Someone still has to do the work, and on a busy day it gets skipped.
Spot the drift early and act. A personal message, approved by your team, sent in time. This is the one that changes the outcome.
What is it worth? At a five-studio group with 2,500 members paying $180 a month, a 5% retention lift is about $270K in kept revenue a year. That is an illustrative example, not a guarantee, but it shows how fast small gains add up across locations.
4. Automate the preparation, never the relationship

No AI will ever be the reason someone loves your studio. Relationships, great coaches, your space and a team that makes people feel welcome stay human. What AI should do is the preparation: notice the behaviour change, remember every member’s history, and draft a message that fits who that member is, so your team can act in minutes.
If I don’t feel I belong in the first few weeks, I quit. Not because of the class or the price. Because I was a stranger.
Soodeh Farokhi, PhD, Founder and CEO, NexScale
5. The operator’s view: knowledge walks out the door

In the live fireside chat moderated by Paula Comfort, Founder of Hire Ground Talent and an FIC Board member, Morgan Thomas shared what changed as Sweat and Tonic grew. At first she knew every member’s name. At a few thousand guests a day, that became impossible. The relationships lived with the front desk and the instructors, and when hourly staff left, that knowledge left with them.
Our data showed how the business was doing, not how each member was engaging. Seeing that up front is a game changer.
Morgan Thomas, Founder and Principal, Forme. Former CBO, Sweat and Tonic
6. Hold every AI vendor to six questions
Including us. The first three matter most.
Do we have to change our member management system? No. It should work on top of the system you already run.
Does it take action, or only report? It should act in your brand voice, not add another dashboard.
Who controls what members receive? Your team approves every message.
How early does it spot risk? Weeks before a cancellation, from visits and bookings.
How will we know it works? Results per location and across the group, against your own baseline.
Is our member data safe? Privacy-first, secure and compliant by design.
Your first four steps

Start this week with your newest members. Then measure 30, 60 and 90-day retention for each location, so you know where the leak is.
Watch the replay and read the report
The 24-minute replay covers Zach’s opening, my presentation and the fireside chat. The webinar insights report brings together the key numbers, the seven lessons, the six vendor questions and a real result from a Canadian studio, along with the FIC member offer.
Want to see what this looks like for your own locations? Book a discovery call and we will walk you through it on your own numbers.
Thank you
Thank you to Zach Weston and the FIC team for your trust and partnership, to Paula Comfort for bringing so many operators into the room, and to Morgan Thomas for an honest operator’s view. And thank you to everyone who joined and asked such sharp questions.
The members you are losing are already telling you. Go and listen to them.
Soodeh Farokhi, PhD, closing the session



